I've resolved the issue with the plugin and it will now, finally, start up again! Unfortunately it was the Skylands plugin, so I couldn't simply disable it. I mean, I could've, but... it would've caused any new (unexplored) chunks out there to generate as vanilla World chunks, which would suck!
However, as I think we are all aware or have realized, the server is not what it once was. Unfortunately I've given it all I've been able to, and have been keeping it all going on some of the savings left over, so that some of the remaining staff could continue working towards shifting the focus from a PJ server and into a Mythology ones. As for me, though, I sadly lack the ambition and motivation. Happy to help if needed, but creatively I am tapped out.
With that said, I think it's time to "pass my Legacy on to the next generation". If anyone is willing to take up that torch then let me know. You should be able to DM me on Discord at Formula350#4025, but otherwise you can still PM me on Enjin. Just keep in mind what sort of undertaking this will be. There's the website, the server, as well as 4 or 5 domain names (though you'd only need to really keep one of them, but it's still at least a yearly fee for the registration). I'll naturally go into the finer details of it all for anyone who does express interest, but you're also going to have to show me that you won't be getting in over your head, and most importantly that you can uphold the CL mission statement.
Our journey isn't over yet, and hopefully our Legacy will continue on with new Crafters! :)